Over and Over Again (1988–2018)

Tracklist

• Digital Media 1
• 1
  The New Flesh (2007‐02‐23 Lille, France + 2000‐01‐14 Yokohama, Japan)
  4:28
• 2
  Somewhat Damaged (2000‐05‐13 Raleigh, North Carolina)
  4:13
• 3
  The Day the World Went Away (LP version) (2018‐12‐08 Los Angeles, California)
  4:30
• 4
  You Know What You Are? (2005‐11‐05 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania)
  3:20
• 5
  Last (2018‐12‐15 Los Angeles, California)
  4:49
• 6
  March of the Pigs (2013‐09‐01 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania + 1994‐11‐13 Columbus, Ohio)
  6:03
• 7
  Piggy (2018‐11‐30 Las Vegas, Nevada)
  4:45
• 8
  All Time Low (2013‐11‐15 Las Vegas, Nevada)
  6:25
• 9
  Find My Way (2013‐10‐24 Atlanta, Georgia)
  5:10
• 10
  That’s What I Get (1990‐02‐17 Melbourne, Florida)
  4:34
• 11
  Various Methods of Escape (2013‐11‐08 Los Angeles, California)
  4:58
• 12
  Right Where It Belongs (2006‐03‐09 Rochester, New York)
  5:06
• 13
  Beside You in Time (2005‐10‐16 San Antonio, Texas)
  4:31
• 14
  Wish (2013‐07‐26 Yuzawa, Japan)
  3:43
• 15
  Metal (2009‐06‐05 Camden, New Jersey)
  6:31
• 16
  Gone, Still (2009‐05‐12 Austin, Texas)
  1:57
• 17
  Lights in the Sky (2009‐05‐09 Tampa, Florida)
  3:31
• 18
  5 Ghosts I (2008‐11‐25 Minneapolis, Minnesota)
  3:06
• 19
  6 Ghosts I (2008‐09‐02 Morrison, Colorado)
  4:41
• 20
  10 Ghosts II (2008‐11‐03 Greensboro, North Carolina)
  2:13
• Digital Media 2
• 1
  Now I’m Nothing (2018‐09‐27 Atlanta, Georgia)
  2:09
• 2
  Terrible Lie (2018‐09‐27 Atlanta, Georgia)
  5:06
• 3
  Sin (theremin) (2000‐01‐15 Osaka, Japan)
  4:20
• 4
  Big Man with a Gun (1994‐05‐26 London, England)
  2:15
• 5
  Head Down (2009‐08‐08 Osaka, Japan)
  3:57
• 6
  Only (2008‐08‐22 Cleveland, Ohio + 2007‐05‐13 Melbourne, Australia + 2014‐07‐18 Pemberton, Canada)
  6:35
• 7
  Every Day Is Exactly the Same (2006‐03‐09 Rochester, New York)
  5:35
• 8
  What if We Could? (2013‐08‐16 Biddinghuizen, Netherlands)
  3:38
• 9
  Me, I’m Not (2007‐08‐05 Vantaa, Finland)
  6:39
• 10
  Digital (2018‐06‐16 Las Vegas, Nevada)
  2:59
• 11
  Disappointed (2014‐08‐25 Los Angeles, California)
  5:51
• 12
  The Big Come Down (2009‐06‐05 Camden, New Jersey)
  4:02
• 13
  Get Down, Make Love (1990‐02‐17 Melbourne, Florida + 2006‐06‐07 Atlanta, Georgia)
  3:18
• 14
  The Mark Has Been Made (2000‐06‐15 Wheatland, California)
  3:45
• 15
  Vessel (2014‐02‐26 Tokyo, Japan)
  5:25
• 16
  Gave Up (1995‐10‐21 Mountain View, California)
  4:41
• 17
  La Mer (2009‐06‐03 Mansfield, Massachusetts)
  7:00
• 18
  The Great Below (1999‐12‐01 London, England)
  5:01
• 19
  The Way Out Is Through (2009‐05‐12 Austin, Texas + 2013‐08‐10 San Francisco, California)
  3:37
• Digital Media 3
• 1
  Pilgrimage (intro) (2007‐02‐10 Lisbon, Portugal)
  1:25
• 2
  Wish (Losing It) (1991‐08‐01 St. Paul, Minnesota)
  4:03
• 3
  Suck (1991‐04‐25 Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania)
  5:25
• 4
  Atmosphere (2009‐08‐28 Chicago, Illinois)

  Nine Inch Nails with Peter Murphy
  4:59
• 5
  Dead Souls (2009‐08‐28 Chicago, Illinois)

  Nine Inch Nails with Peter Murphy
  5:34
• 6
  Kick in the Eye (2009‐08‐25 New York City, New York)

  Nine Inch Nails with Peter Murphy
  3:15
• 7
  Reptile (2009‐08‐26 New York City, New York)

  Nine Inch Nails with Peter Murphy
  7:23
• 8
  A Strange Kind of Love / Bela Lugosi’s Dead (2009‐08‐26 New York City, New York)

  Nine Inch Nails with Peter Murphy
  4:51
• 9
  Final Solution (2009‐08‐29 Chicago, Illinois)

  Nine Inch Nails with Peter Murphy
  5:20
• 10
  Kick Out the Jams (2009‐05‐16 Chula Vista, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Street Sweeper Social Club
  3:19
• 11
  Survivalism (2009‐05‐10 Atlanta, Georgia)

  Nine Inch Nails with Saul Williams
  5:08
• 12
  Banged and Blown Through (2009‐05‐10 Atlanta, Georgia)

  Nine Inch Nails with Saul Williams
  4:04
• 13
  African Student Movement (2005‐10‐29 New Orleans, Louisiana)

  Nine Inch Nails with Saul Williams
  4:41
• 14
  List of Demands (Reparations) (2005‐10‐29 New Orleans, Louisiana)

  Nine Inch Nails with Saul Williams
  3:31
• 15
  Animal (1996‐09‐05 New York City, New York)

  Nine Inch Nails with Kevin McMahon
  5:02
• 16
  Tough (1996‐09‐05 New York City, New York)

  Nine Inch Nails with Kevin McMahon
  4:10
• 17
  R.S.V.P. (1996‐09‐05 New York City, New York)

  Nine Inch Nails with Clint Mansell
  4:37
• 18
  Wise Up! Sucker (1996‐09‐05 New York City, New York)

  Nine Inch Nails with Clint Mansell
  3:22
• 19
  Starfuckers, Inc. (2000‐05‐09 New York City, New York)

  Nine Inch Nails with Marilyn Manson
  5:12
• 20
  The Beautiful People (2000‐05‐09 New York City, New York)

  Nine Inch Nails with Marilyn Manson
  3:57
• Digital Media 4
• 1
  HYPERPOWER! (2007‐08‐16 Salzburg, Austria)
  1:41
• 2
  The Beginning of the End (2009‐06‐05 Camden, New Jersey)
  2:45
• 3
  Less Than (2018‐06‐16 Las Vegas, Nevada)
  3:33
• 4
  Love Is Not Enough (2005‐06‐15 Berlin, Germany)
  4:00
• 5
  Twist (1988‐10‐31 New York City, New York)
  5:47
• 6
  Came Back Haunted (2013‐11‐18 Portland, Oregon)
  6:18
• 7
  Ruiner (1994‐11‐13 Columbus, Ohio)
  5:04
• 8
  Down in It (1994‐05‐26 London, England + 2006‐06‐25 Clarkston, Michigan)
  4:39
• 9
  The Warning (2014‐02‐28 Tokyo, Japan)
  3:56
• 10
  The Background World (2018‐12‐08 Los Angeles, California)
  3:57
• 11
  The Loop Closes (2017‐07‐31 New York City, New York)
  1:25
• 12
  The Great Destroyer (2014‐02‐28 Tokyo, Japan)
  5:45
• 13
  Burning Bright (Field on Fire) (2018‐12‐03 San Francisco, California)
  5:43
• 14
  Copy of A (2013‐08‐16 Biddinghuizen, Netherlands)
  5:42
• 15
  Sanctified (1995‐10‐11 St. Louis, Missouri)
  7:07
• 16
  1 Ghosts I (2008‐07‐26 Seattle, Washinton)
  2:48
• 17
  25 Ghosts III (2008‐07‐26 Seattle, Washington)
  2:22
• 18
  19 Ghosts III (2008‐09‐02 Morrison, Colorado)
  2:32
• 19
  Piggy (Ghosts version) (2008‐11‐18 Fort Wayne, Indiana)
  6:11
• 20
  The Greater Good (2008‐11‐09 Worcester, Massachusetts)
  4:39
• Digital Media 5
• 1
  Pinion (2008‐11‐08 Manchester, New Hampshire + 1995‐01‐06 Uniondale, New York)
  2:29
• 2
  Mr. Self Destruct (2009‐05‐15 Phoenix, Arizona + 2018‐12‐01 Las Vegas, Nevada)
  4:52
• 3
  Heresy (2007‐08‐01 Budapest, Hungary)
  3:59
• 4
  Satellite (2013‐11‐08 Los Angeles, California)
  5:12
• 5
  Running (2013‐10‐12 Uncasville, Connecticut)
  4:12
• 6
  I Would for You (2013‐09‐28 St. Paul, Minnesota)
  4:33
• 7
  Sin (1990‐07‐27 Chicago, Illinois)
  3:24
• 8
  No, You Don’t (2000‐01‐11 Tokyo, Japan + 2007‐08‐01 Budapest, Hungary)
  4:15
• 9
  Getting Smaller (2005‐04‐28 San Francisco, California)
  3:38
• 10
  Survivalism (2013‐11‐18 Portland, Oregon)
  4:19
• 11
  Closer (2005‐05‐21 Atlanta, Georgia + 2008‐11‐25 Minneapolis, Minnesota)
  5:25
• 12
  Capital G (2007‐05‐20 Tokyo, Japan)
  3:43
• 13
  31 Ghosts IV (2014‐02‐26 Tokyo, Japan)
  2:24
• 14
  Reptile (2018‐11‐23 New Orleans, Louisiana)
  5:55
• 15
  Help Me I Am in Hell (2007‐02‐23 Lille, France)
  3:21
• 16
  Happiness in Slavery (1994‐11‐21 Tampa, Florida + 1994‐12‐29 Dayton, Ohio)
  6:59
• 17
  A Warm Place (2013‐11‐16 Las Vegas, Nevada)
  3:04
• 18
  Eraser (1994‐12‐29 Dayton, Ohio)
  4:46
• 19
  Hurt (1994‐12‐29 Dayton, Ohio)
  4:59
• 20
  The Downward Spiral (1994‐12‐29 Dayton, Ohio)
  3:40
• Digital Media 6
• 1
  The Eater of Dreams (2018‐06‐13 Las Vegas, Nevada)
  0:45
• 2
  Hand Covers Bruise (2014‐02‐28 Tokyo, Japan)
  1:53
• 3
  Adrift and at Peace (2006‐10‐22 San Francisco, California)
  2:10
• 4
  The Fragile (2009‐07‐02 Arvika, Sweden)
  5:18
• 5
  The Day the World Went Away (2009‐05‐22 Mountain View, California)
  5:51
• 6
  Even Deeper (2013‐11‐08 Los Angeles, California)
  6:17
• 7
  Atmosphere (2009‐09‐10 Los Angeles, California)
  4:50
• 8
  8 Ghosts I (2008‐08‐29 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania)
  3:01
• 9
  21 Ghosts III (2008‐11‐08 Manchester, New Hampshire)
  2:51
• 10
  28 Ghosts IV (2008‐12‐13 Las Vegas, Nevada)
  5:02
• 11
  I Can’t Give Everything Away (Farewell mix) (2017‐07‐30 New York City, New York)
  3:38
• 12
  Subterraneans (2018‐12‐08 Los Angeles, California + 2018‐11‐30 Las Vegas, Nevada)
  5:44
• 13
  The Frail (2018‐12‐08 Los Angeles, California + 2018‐09‐27 Atlanta, Georgia)
  1:59
• 14
  The Wretched (2013‐10‐12 Uncasville, Connecticut)
  5:27
• 15
  Not So Pretty Now (2009‐05‐12 Austin, Texas)
  4:05
• 16
  Dear World, (2018‐09‐26 Atlanta, Georgia)
  4:47
• 17
  Physical (You’re So) (2009‐09‐06 Los Angeles, California)
  4:40
• 18
  Kinda I Want To (1989‐12‐07 Boston, Massachusetts + 1988‐10‐31 New York City, New York)
  5:27
• 19
  Parasite (2018‐06‐16 Las Vegas, Nevada)
  4:44
• 20
  Something I Can Never Have (1994‐05‐26 London, England)
  6:42
• Digital Media 7
• 1
  Greensleeves (2018‐12‐15 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Mike Garson
  3:20
• 2
  Just Like You Imagined (2018‐12‐15 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Mike Garson
  4:36
• 3
  La Mer (2018‐12‐15 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Mike Garson
  4:00
• 4
  Eraser (2009‐09‐10 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Mike Garson
  4:57
• 5
  The Becoming (2009‐09‐10 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Mike Garson
  5:44
• 6
  I Do Not Want This (2009‐09‐08 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Mike Garson
  5:56
• 7
  Down in the Park (piano intro) (2009‐09‐08 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Mike Garson
  4:38
• 8
  Down in the Park (2009‐09‐08 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Gary Numan and Mike Garson
  4:03
• 9
  Metal (2009‐09‐08 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Gary Numan and Mike Garson
  6:17
• 10
  I Die: You Die (2009‐09‐10 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Gary Numan and Mike Garson
  3:40
• 11
  Cars (2009‐09‐08 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Gary Numan, Eric Avery, and Mike Garson
  4:18
• 12
  Anthrax (2009‐09‐08 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Gary Numan, Eric Avery and HEALTH
  7:05
• 13
  Reptile (2013‐10‐31 Orlando, Florida)

  Nine Inch Nails with Gary Numan
  7:27
• 14
  We Take Mystery to Bed (2013‐10‐31 Orlando, Florida)

  Nine Inch Nails with Gary Numan
  4:46
• 15
  Wish (2009‐09‐10 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Dillinger Escape Plan
  4:09
• 16
  On the Wing (2018‐12‐14 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Mike Garson & Mariqueen Maandig‐Reznor
  5:32
• 17
  In This Twilight (2018‐12‐14 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Mike Garson
  4:03
• Digital Media 8
• 1
  The Fireman (intro) (2018‐08‐17 Tokyo, Japan)
  2:32
• 2
  Branches/Bones (2018‐12‐12 Los Angeles, California)
  1:50
• 3
  Shit Mirror (2018‐12‐15 Los Angeles, California)
  3:07
• 4
  Ahead of Ourselves (2018‐12‐15 Los Angeles, California)
  3:29
• 5
  God Break Down the Door (2018‐12‐15 Los Angeles, California)
  5:28
• 6
  The Good Soldier (2013‐07‐26 Yuzawa, Japan)
  4:40
• 7
  The Line Begins to Blur (2009‐06‐05 Camden, New Jersey)
  4:01
• 8
  She’s Gone Away (2017‐07‐31 New York City, New York)
  4:31
• 9
  The Lovers (2018‐12‐04 San Francisco, California)
  4:15
• 10
  Meet Your Master (2009‐05‐30 Noblesville, Indiana)
  4:01
• 11
  Ringfinger (1990‐02‐25 Charlotte, North Carolina)
  6:07
• 12
  God Given (2008‐09‐02 Morrison, Colorado)
  3:45
• 13
  Complication (2000‐05‐13 Raleigh, North Carolina)
  1:58
• 14
  Suck (1994‐04‐20 Seattle, Washington + 2005‐08‐20 Sydney, Australia + 2006‐06‐10 Charlottle, North Carolina)
  6:38
• 15
  The Only Time (1994‐11‐21 Tampa, Florida)
  5:24
• 16
  Starfuckers, Inc. (2006‐06‐06 Birmingham, Alabama)
  6:37
• 17
  The Perfect Drug (2018‐12‐15 Los Angeles, California)
  5:12
• 18
  I Do Not Want This (1994‐10‐03 Universal City, California)
  6:13
• 19
  Right Where It Belongs (v2) (2009‐05‐08 West Palm Beach, Florida)
  5:00
• Digital Media 9
• 1
  999,999 (2008‐08‐13 Duluth, Georgia)
  0:54
• 2
  1,000,000 (2009‐05‐10 Atlanta, Georgia)
  5:06
• 3
  Please (2000‐01‐15 Osaka, Japan + 2006‐03‐10 Amherst, Massachusetts)
  3:31
• 4
  In Two (2013‐10‐19 University Park, Pennsylvania)
  5:54
• 5
  Closer to God (1995‐09‐20 Toronto, Canada)
  4:08
• 6
  The Collector (2009‐09‐06 Los Angeles, California)
  3:42
• 7
  Banged and Blown Through (2009‐06‐05 Camden, New Jersey)
  4:48
• 8
  This Isn’t the Place (2018‐12‐15 Los Angeles, California)
  5:39
• 9
  Home (2009‐08‐08 Osaka, Japan)
  3:42
• 10
  Deep (2006‐03‐13 Knoxville, Tennessee)
  4:15
• 11
  Sanctified (v2) (2018‐12‐11 Los Angeles, California)
  5:03
• 12
  La Mer (piano) (2007‐02‐10 Lisbon, Portugal)
  3:03
• 13
  Into the Void (2013‐10‐05 Cleveland, Ohio)
  4:05
• 14
  With Teeth (2005‐03‐23 Fresno, California)
  6:06
• 15
  Discipline (2008‐12‐13 Las Vegas, Nevada)
  4:23
• 16
  Just Like You Imagined (2000‐06‐10 Portland, Oregon)
  3:40
• 17
  We’re in This Together (2007‐04‐04 Frankfurt, Germany)
  6:12
• 18
  The Hand that Feeds (2013‐07‐26 Yuzawa, Japan)
  3:31
• 19
  Head Like a Hole (1994‐05‐26 London, England)
  7:01
• Digital Media 10
• 1
  Live Hate (intro) (1990‐07‐11 Washington, DC)
  3:19
• 2
  Terrible Lie (1990‐07‐11 Washington, DC)
  4:55
• 3
  Supernaut (1990‐08‐09 New York City, New York)

  Trent Reznor with Revolting Cocks
  4:00
• 4
  Maybe Just Once (1988‐10‐31 New York City, New York)
  5:06
• 5
  Physical (You’re So) (1995‐01‐06 Uniondale, New York)

  Nine Inch Nails with Adam Ant
  4:43
• 6
  Red Scab (1995‐01‐06 Uniondale, New York)

  Nine Inch Nails with Adam Ant
  4:03
• 7
  Beat My Guest (1995‐01‐06 Uniondale, New York)

  Nine Inch Nails with Adam Ant
  4:09
• 8
  BBB (2018‐12‐15 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Mariqueen Maandig‐Reznor
  3:34
• 9
  Welcome Oblivion (2018‐12‐15 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Mariqueen Maandig‐Reznor
  3:58
• 10
  Ice Age (2018‐12‐15 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Mariqueen Maandig‐Reznor
  6:33
• 11
  Parasite (2018‐12‐07 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Mariqueen Maandig‐Reznor
  4:50
• 12
  A Drowning (2018‐12‐07 Los Angeles, California)

  Nine Inch Nails with Mariqueen Maandig‐Reznor
  5:36
• 13
  Eraser (instrumental) (1995‐10‐11 St. Louis, Missouri)
  4:04
• 14
  Subterraneans (1995‐10‐11 St. Louis, Missouri)

  Nine Inch Nails with David Bowie
  4:27
• 15
  Scary Monsters (and Super Creeps) (1995‐10‐11 St. Louis, Missouri)

  Nine Inch Nails with David Bowie
  5:17
• 16
  Reptile (1995‐10‐11 St. Louis, Missouri)

  Nine Inch Nails with David Bowie
  6:23
• 17
  Hallo Spaceboy (1995‐10‐11 St. Louis, Missouri)

  Nine Inch Nails with David Bowie
  5:09
• 18
  Hurt (1995‐10‐11 St. Louis, Missouri)

  Nine Inch Nails with David Bowie
  5:59
  2.0 ★
• Digital Media 11
• 1
  The Downward Spiral / The New Flesh (2014‐05‐27 Amsterdam, Netherlands)
  1:18
• 2
  Echoplex (2009‐05‐20 Irvine, California)
  5:08
• 3
  Non‐Entity (2006‐06‐20 Hartford, Connecticut)
  3:36
• 4
  17 Ghosts II (2008‐11‐18 Fort Wayne, Indiana)
  2:16
• 5
  32 Ghosts IV (2008‐08‐12 Knoxville, Tennessee)
  4:26
• 6
  14 Ghosts II (2008‐11‐18 Fort Wayne, Indiana)
  3:24
• 7
  Corona Radiata (2008‐10‐04 Santiago, Chile)
  2:06
• 8
  Letting You (2014‐04‐05 São Paulo, Brazil)
  3:54
• 9
  Piggy (Nothing Can Stop Me Now) (1995‐10‐11 St. Louis, Missouri + 2008‐08‐29 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania)
  5:52
• 10
  I’m Afraid of Americans (2018‐11‐23 New Orleans, Louisiana)
  5:15
• 11
  Burn (2009‐08‐08 Osaka, Japan + 2018‐12‐12 Los Angeles, California)
  6:06
• 12
  Closer (album version) (1999‐11‐28 Tilburg, Netherlands + 2000‐01‐15 Osaka, Japan)
  6:18
• 13
  Dead Souls (2009‐05‐15 Phoenix, Arizona + 1995‐01‐06 Uniondale, New York)
  4:38
• 14
  The Becoming (1995‐10‐11 St. Louis, Missouri)
  4:56
• 15
  All the Love in the World (2013‐11‐21 Vancouver, Canada)
  5:09
• 16
  While I’m Still Here (Black Noise outro) (2013‐10‐12 Uncasville, Connecticut)
  5:37
• 17
  And All That Could Have Been (2018‐10‐26 Chicago, Illinois)
  5:55
• 18
  Over and Out (2018‐12‐15 Los Angeles, California)
  5:21
• 19
  In This Twilight (Zero‐Sum outro) (2013‐09‐28 St. Paul, Minnesota)
  5:53

More by Nine Inch Nails

The Downward Spiral

The Downward Spiral 1994

Pretty Hate Machine

Pretty Hate Machine 1989

TRON: Ares: Original Motion Picture Soundtrack

TRON: Ares: Original Motion Picture Soundtrack 2025

Ghosts V: Together

Ghosts V: Together 2020

Hesitation Marks

Hesitation Marks 2013

Year Zero

Year Zero 2007

Release credits

• Aaron North
  guitar [5.12, 9.10]
• Alessandro Cortini
  electronic instruments [11.5, 11.5-6, 11.6, 9.10, 5.12, 4.17-18, 1.13, 1.18, 1.18-20, 1.20]
• Alex Carapetis
  drums (drum set) [13]
• Charlie Clouser
  electronic instruments [8.13, 9.5]
• Chris Vrenna
  drums (drum set) [5]
• Danny Lohner
  bass guitar [8.13, 9.5]
• Jeordie White
  bass guitar [5.12, 1.13, 9.10]
• Jerome Dillon
  drums (drum set) [13]
• Josh Freese
  drums (drum set) [9.10, 1.18, 1.20, 5.12, 11.5-6, 4.18], membranophone [11.5-6, 4.17, 1.18-20]
• Justin Meldal‐Johnsen
  bass guitar [1.18-20, 11.5-6, 4.17-18]
• Robin Finck
  guitar [1.18-20, 4.17-18, 9.5, 8.13, 11.5-6]

Issues

• 

  O
  Over and Over Again (1988–2018)

  11x Digital Media
  5 July 2019